The Truth About Vegan Meat Substitutes
By Dr. Justin Marchegiani
The number of meat-alternatives has grown exponentially in recent years, all you have to do is walk into your local grocery store to see for yourself. But are these faux meats healthier and more environmentally conscious than eating the real thing?
Vegan vs. Vegetarian
Who is buying meat alternatives? These are targeted towards vegans and vegetarians, who also call their diet “plant-based”.
- Vegetarians avoid eating meat; though some eat fish (those in the fish-eating subgroup are called “pescitarians”)
- Vegans avoid all animal products, including meat, honey, eggs, milk, etc.
Some popular reasons for switching to a plant-based diet include:
- Animal welfare/anti-factory farming
- Environmental reasons
- Personal health reasons (disease, obesity, other illnesses)
Meat Alternatives: Nutrition
Let’s look at burgers. A typical beef burger contains:
Now, here are just some of the ingredients in one of the most popular veggie burgers:
- SOY FLOUR, WHEAT GLUTEN, VEGETABLE OIL (CORN, CANOLA, AND/OR SUNFLOWER OIL), SOY SAUCE POWDER (SOY SAUCE [SOYBEANS, SALT, WHEAT]), SUGAR
Many meat alternatives, like veggie burgers and sausages, are ultra-processed foods that contain soy, gluten, canola oil, artificial flavors, and chemical binders. Let’s take a closer look at the impact of some of these common ingredients:
- Soy: Most people who have heard negative things about soy have heard of its estrogen-mimicking effects, and how it has caused men to grow breasts. Studies have also shown soy reduces sperm count, and harms thyroid function.
A common concern for those on a meatless diet are nutritional deficiencies. Sadly, soy is commonly eaten by vegetarians and vegans, either as an ingredient in meat alternatives, and also as tofu. Soy is high in th antinutrient phytic acid, which inhibits nutrient absorption. This means that any meal containing soy is going to automatically have lower nutritional value. Iron, zinc, calcium, manganese, and magnesium are some of the nutrients that are prevented from being fully absorbed and utilized when you eat soy.
Soy is also high in lectins, which are linked to leaky gut, inflammation and autoimmune reactions. Additionally, over 80% of soy is genetically modified, which is a huge health issue, as well as massive environmental problem we will discuss later in this article.
- Wheat/Gluten: Gluten is a protein found in grains such as wheat, barley, and rye. While some people have Celiac disease (a true allergy to gluten), a large portion of the population is estimated to have gluten intolerance. Covering all things gluten is much bigger than the scope of this article, but if you suffer from digestive issues, brain fog, headaches, mood swings, chronic fatigue, muscle and joint pain, infertility, or skin problems- you may want to consider getting rid of gluten.
In fact, gluten (like soy) is considered an antinutrient, and whether or not you have a diagnosed gluten sensitivity you’re probably going to be better off getting it out of your diet.
As an antinutrient, gluten blocks the absorption of essential vitamins and nutrients, can cause digestive issues like bloating, gas, and irregular bowel movements, and is linked to leaky gut. These effects can lead to more serious and chronic issues.
- Vegetable Oil: Los Angeles Lakers nutritionist Dr. Cate Shanahan calls vegetable oils “liquid death” because they are chemically unstable and cause free radical damage.
Additionally, vegetable oils tend to be low in beneficial saturated fat, and high in inflammatory omega-6. Soy, corn, canola, and other vegetable oils are correlated with obesity, oxidative stress, inflammation, and heart disease.
- Sugar: Sugar has been linked to an increased risk of a variety of chronic diseases and illnesses including obesity, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, cognitive decline and some forms of cancer. Sugar depletes the body of critical electrolytes, antioxidants, and minerals, which leads to cell death, muscle spasms, insulin resistance, and other health defects. Its effects on the immune system leave you prone to getting sick more often and more severely. There is no rational reason for sugar to be added into meat substitutes.
All of these ingredients are linked to weight gain, inflammation, brain fog, and other negative health issues that are unheard of from your standard grass-fed beef burger.
There are many vegetarians and vegans who choose this diet for reasons pertaining to the environment and animal rights. In fact, many university dining halls and otherwise meat-eating people around the nation have adopted “Meatless Mondays” to reduce their meat consumption one day a week. The truth is, the environmental and humane impacts of eating meat vs. eating plant-based are complicated.
I always advocate choosing grass-fed meat. It’s better for you, it’s better for the animal. While factory farming and feedlots are obviously horrible for everyone involved, choosing grass-fed, free-range beef is a much better option. In fact, happy cows help fertilize the land and maintain nutrient diversity of the soil. Without them, we would have depend on artificial fertilizers that throw the ecosystem, and our health, out of balance.
Harvesting the crops for the ingredients used in veggie burgers may not always be ecologically sound. Industrial farming practices oftentimes harm bees and other small creatures. While eating beef does sacrifice the life of the cow, it’s worth considering the lives lost to in the industrial practices involved in making meat-alternatives.
Another important note to consider, whether you eat meat or plant-based: As mentioned earlier, over 80% soy is GMO. The use of RoundUp, glyphosate, and other toxic pesticides is increasing. The damage it is doing to our health, the ecosystem, and the quality of food is undeniable. Monsanto, the creator of chemical Agent Orange used in the Vietnam War, is now taking over the world as a leading producer of GMO seeds and herbicides. This is a big topic worthy of its own article, but the takeaway I want you to have is that Monsanto crops are linked to cancer and DNA damage. As a vegetarian, this is especially important to realize, as many of the top GMO/glyphosate-sprayed crops are used excessively in meat alternatives and as vegan sources of protein. These include: soy, canola oil, corn, and sugar.
The choice to go vegan or vegetarian to protect the environment and animals is admirable. This article is meant to be thought-provoking, hopefully providing some food-for-thought for those who already are eating a plant-based diet make healthier choices, and providing an alternate viewpoint for those considering plant-based vs. meat-eating.
Why Should You Go Organic?
By Dr. Justin Marchegiani
Today eating organic has been the trendy thing of late. Add gluten free and paleo to the mix and it just makes it even more confusing. Alright so let’s break it down… What is organic actually?
Organic Food: Is food that isn’t grown with pesticides, herbicides, fungicides and is GMO free. Depending on the organic certification some are stricter than others. Certain certifications require farm fields to have not used pesticides for at least 3 years and others are much looser in regards to their regulations. Your best bet is to get to know some local farmers in your area and figure out what standards they adhere to. You may even find many farmers don’t bother paying for an organic certification even though their crops are just as good as organic ones.
Check out www.eatwild.com or www.eatwiththeseasons.com to figure out where you can access local organic food and farms in your area. Many towns have local farmers markets that meet weekly in downtown areas and sell their goods directly to consumers.
In regards to animals, organic refers to animals that haven’t been injected or fed various medications including hormones, antibiotics or foods that were produced with pesticides or other chemical agents.
Again animals can still be fed an unnatural diet, I.E. chickens being fed soy and flax and cows being fed grains. It’s important to know what is natural for a given animal’s diet, organic or not, if an animal isn’t designed to consume it, the animal won’t be as healthy for you to eat as it could have been.
Remember, healthy animals help make a healthy you. It’s virtually impossible to consume sick and toxic animals and plants and expect to create health out of it. Said another way, you can’t make chicken salad out of chicken crap.
The Benefits: So eating organic does provide many benefits. The first is that you are not providing additional toxins to your body from all of the above mentioned toxins that are abundant in conventional farming. That alone is a huge plus! Research also shows a robust increase in nutritional value when comparing organic food to non-organic.
The pesticides and other chemicals that are used in conventional farming have a terrible effect on the microbiota and minerals that are present in the soil. Plants can only be as healthy as the soil, so healthy soil=healthy plants that taste good and are nutritionally dense.
There is a great deal of misinformation put out there by multi-national corporation like general mills or Kellogg’s to name a few that say, organic and conventional food have the same nutritional value.
These huge corporations have created their own organic labels, and have thus downgraded the overall meaning of what organic represents and stands for. When you compare organic food from a local farmer who practices organic farming methods, you will see these conventional foods don’t hold a candle to it.
Again even if the nutritional value doesn’t sell you on going organic, just the fact that you aren’t consuming know carcinogenic hormone disrupting toxins should be enough of a benefit by itself.
Cool Story… Did you know that researchers at the University of Florida found that in the everglades female alligators weren’t reproducing at a normal rate due to the severe reduction in size of their male alligators’ genitalia! All the males reading this post, I hope I have your attention by now!
When these male alligators’ blood was drawn, they had nearly the same estrogen levels of their female counterparts. Researchers have attributed the pesticide run off as the cause because of its estrogen like effects (xeno-estrogens). These synthetic estrogens play a major role in infertility, decreased libido and muscle mass in men and women alike.
PS: These same estrogen’s are also found in plastics too. If you are drinking or eating out of plastic containers, you may want to switch to glass or stainless steel containers.
Reference: The Disappearing Male (Documentary)
Take Home Message:
- Eat organic, ideally from local farmer that you know.
- If money is an issue, at the very least eat from foods with a lower pesticide residue. Please See “The Clean 15 and Dirty Dozen” below. These foods are categorized by the lowest and highest level of pesticide residue. Avoid the high residue plants and consume the low residue ones.
- Just do it! No arm chair quarterbacks here. Give it a try for a few months, add in some healthy animals products too and see if how you look, feel or perform improves.